|
http://www.collectorsmusicreviews.com
Previously,
this recording was only available via download or on fan-produced
CDR’s such as Hyde Park and
Black Hills Garden Party.
Thus,
Atom Hyde Park marks the silver debut of this recording, and
although it is a bit rougher
than much of the output on Godfather Records, due to its historical
value and rarity, Godfather elected to press
it regardless.
I certainly applaud the label for striving to produce
new factory-pressed titles as opposed to simply
rehashing the same concerts over and over like some of the other
labels are often prone to do.
As always,
Atom Hyde Park is housed in a
gorgeous tri-fold cardboard sleeve, featuring several photos from
the
actual performance and some background information on the concert.
Godfather’s packaging is always the epitome
of professionalism, and unique also for the use of brighter colours
than many of the other labels.
Of course,
it is the content that matters the most here, and sonically I’d
characterize this recording as favoring the mids,more or less bereft of low end, and no extreme high-end.
Due to the
frequency range, there is a mild amount of
upper-end distortion during some of the louder passages but on the
whole, the music comes through much clearer than
on some of the other festival performances of 1970.
It should be
noted also that this recording is remarkably free of the
hiss that often plagues sources of this era and there are no
drop-outs to report, but the tape does sound worn in spots.
The only cuts present are prior to “Atom Heart Mother,” after Roger
Waters explained there would be a pause to bring
out the choir and brass ensemble, and for 1 second at the 1:51 mark
of the same song.
Atmospherically, being that this was an open air festival, the wind
sometimes plays a role in the sonic character of
the recording, so occasionally there is something of a panning
effect, however in my opinion this only enhances the trippy,
psychedelic nature of the setlist!
David
Gilmour’s guitar and Richard Wright’s organ tend to dominate this
recording instrumentally, yet all of the vocals
are clear, thus despite the “raw” nature of the recording, it is
quite enjoyable to listen to.
The audience are
obviously mesmerized, listening intently, and primarily only audible
between songs (barring a couple instances
during softer passages, where the chatter actually contributes in a
good way!).
The
recording begins with a gentle fade-in during the “Intro” already in
progress; it’s unclear how much is missing here,
but I can’t imagine much.
Though it’s more or less the standard
“Pink Blues” that was usually reserved for many an encore,
we are treated to a fabulous bluesy solo from Mr. Gilmour, supported
by sustained chords from Wright’s Hammond.
'
Jams like these make it very clear that Gilmour is every bit the
blues-master as Clapton or Page, albeit with
pitch as consistent as his vocals, even during his most expressive
bends.
(That’s no slight on Clapton or Page mind you,just pointing out that Gilmour deserves no less respect in this
regard!)
“Intro”
segues seamlessly into “Embryo,” where the tempo picks up without
missing a beat, and this arrangement
actually works very well. '
The aforementioned wind factor impacts the
first couple minutes of “Embryo” the most,
but almost functions as an additional layer along with the audience,
leading into and through the “seagull” section.
According to Mark Blake’s fabulous Floyd bio
Comfortably Numb, “the sound of
children giggling and chattering
echoed around the park, causing many looks of stoned confusion amid
the crowd, until they realised that the sounds
were actually coming from Richard Wright’s keyboards.” Trippy indeed.
While
nowhere the length it would reach
during concerts the following year, and fairly restrained overall, ”Embryo” still
makes for a great opener.
The pastoral
“Green Is The Colour” was often the most tuneful song performed
during this era, and the concert at
Hyde Park is no exception, unfolding from a soft, sentimental folk
melody and building dynamically to a
rocking climax before abruptly shifting into “Careful With That Axe
Eugene.”
This is not necessarily their best segue
for this pairing, ending with a sudden bang (possibly a small cut),
but Wright’s haunting organ almost instantly
pulls you back in here.
This is a
fairly mature, subdued rendition of “Careful With That Axe Eugene,”
but totally in line with rest of the
performance - perhaps the band had some timing restrictions to take
into account being that this was a festival or
maybe they just didn’t want to “freak out” their choir and brass
section with psychedelic excess?
It’s an enjoyable version nonetheless, full of the haunting
atmosphere we all love this song for.
Despite being a bit in the background, there is a wicked flurry of
percussion courtesy of Nick Mason
worth mentioning beginning at the 5:00 mark that builds to a
fantastic crescendo before the calm ensues again
some 34 seconds later.
One of the
highlights of this set is the amazing version of “Set The Controls
For The Heart Of The Sun,” introduced
by
Roger Waters as being “the last oldie before we do something new.”
Metamorphosing from an introspective meditation
first into a raga-style freak-out roughly 4 minutes in, replete with
Roger’s gongwork and Mason’s frenzied percussion,
then onto a deep space reflection lead by Wright’s delayed keyboards
and garnished with Gilmour’s delayed
slidework, before the final recapitulation of the verse/chorus.
Absolutely transcendental, and extremely enjoyable to navigate, it’s
quite possible that I was as transfixed as the
audience (from 7:22-10:00 in particular)!
As noted
above, there is a brief cut before “Atom Heart Mother,” I assume to
conserve tape while the additional
musicians took to the stage, but no music is missing (even the 2nd
cut at 1:51 affects only a fraction of a second).
Officially christened “Atom Heart Mother,” only two days prior at
the BBC Paris Cinema, the name was taken
from newspaper headlines at the last minute so the band could
register the song for the purpose of royalties.
This
performance cycles from the brass ensemble to the band before
yielding to the haunting chorale and onto the f
unky mid-section. The massive work culminates in a powerful reprise
with all of the musicians performing together.
It should be noted that the brass and choir do come through with
great clarity on this recording as well.
When all is
said and done, Atom Hyde Park is
a welcome and worthy addition to the collection of any serious
Floyd aficionado, and although it is a bit rough around the edges,
it does sound better than many of the other
festival recordings of Floyd from 1970.
The drums and bass certainly
suffer the most, but the other elements are
very much audible and remarkably clear for an open air audience
recording this old. I reckon this is one of the more
“tripped out” recordings of Floyd for the plethora of reasons
detailed above, and there is no disputing the rarity or
value of this concert, thus I applaud Godfather once again for
giving the real collectors something fresh to savor.
|