PINK FLOYD

 
Review
The Best Of Tour 72 (Siréne-135)

 

 

http://www.collectorsmusicreviews.com

 

Pink Floyd’s show at the Rainbow Theater on February 20th was the last of four nights at that venue and the final of their short tour of the UK promoting their newly written concept LP Eclipse aka Dark Side Of The Moon.
The first half of the show featuring those numbers was recorded and released on one of the most popular vinyl titles from the 70’s.

It is so good many thought it was a soundboard recording or a BBC radio broadcast.
No record of any broadcast exists and it is definitely an audience recording (there is muffled conversation in the lower
right channel).
Tapes exists for the earlier shows on the UK tour but this is the best sounding of them all and give us a great recording of Dark Side in its earliest stages.

This recording is many people’s very first listen to what would be on of the most important and highest selling rock LP’s in history.
The vinyl release The Best Of Tour ‘72 (16-421/422) originated in Europe and was quickly copied in the US and Japan and has been in circulation ever since.
The Swingin’ Pig Records released The Best Of Tour 72 (TSP-CD-049) in 1990 on compact disc.

This is one of the titles produced by this label, along with Liver’ Than You’ll Ever Be, which was criticized for their heavy handed mastering using the No-Noise which eliminated the hiss but also clipped the music too producing a horrible sounding affect.
Dark Side Of The Sky (Chapter One CO 25117), Forbidden Samples (Neutral Zone NZCD 89007) and The Live Side of The Moon (Seagull Records) are other releases of this tape but the current progressive rock labels have ignored it until the current release on Sirene.

The first two discs present the excellent sounding but incomplete tape in two different stages.
Disc number two presents a copy of the original European vinyl release.
The first disc is the same except speed corrected, the tape deterioration at the end of “On The Run” is improved and given the Sirene mastering process which makes the tape sound much more warm and full.

The job they did is really nice and the sound quality is phenomenal.
There are three cuts on the tape at 3:37 in “Time”, at 2:00 into “Us & Them” eliminating most of the song, and a fade out at 1:10 in “Eclipse”. The second two discs cover the complete performance from a second tape source.
It makes its debut on a silver title and is a complete good audience recording.
It is a distance from the stage and has noticeable hiss. Some of the quieter passages are a somewhat difficult to hear, but the main virtue of the tape is to allow us to hear the entire concert.

“On The Run” is the same arrangement they played throughout the entire year until the LP was released, being a jam between Wright and Gilmour.
This version is very intense with Gilmour reaching a tense crescendo before segueing into “Time”.
”Money” has the long bass intro and an extended guitar solo at the end.
It sounds like someone missed a cue as happened in the following song “Us & Them”.

Wright misses the time signatures at the beginning and extends the measures two extra beats until Mason comes in and gets the band back on track.
“Eclipse” ends with very loud sirens going off in the theater which impressed the newspapers in their reviews the following week.
After “One Of These Days” Waters says: “There are people outside with petition…anti-all-this midnight assembly rubbish which is going through Parliament, so if you can sign it when you go out…”

“Careful With That Axe, Eugene” sounds very creepy in this recording and comes very close to The Doors’ “Not To Touch The Earth” (I sometimes believe that track is Waters’ Jim Morrison tribute).
”A Saucerful Of Secrets” closes the set on a high note despite Wright’s miscue in “Storm Signal”.
His wandering head drove the band to the brink several times during the show.
The Band play the “Pink Floyd Blues” as the first encore, introduced by Waters as “something different”.
This is the same blues melody they played throughout their career and can be heard on many and various live tapes.

The Best Of Tour ‘72 is another great release by Siréne. I applaud their decision to not edit the two tape sources together as has been done by some collectors.
As such, this is a nice archive of all of the sources that exist for this important date.

They also respect the history to reproduce the cover of the European vinyl with the picture of momma smiling pig and her piglets.
The back cover is reproduced on the inside too.
All this is printed on the glossy high quality paper that makes this a classy presentation and one of the many essential Siréne Pink Floyd titles to own.

#################################################################################

 

◆P.FLOYD THE BEST OF TOUR 72 (Sirene-135)(4CD)

 

◆いつもの超定番ライブ720220 ファクトリープレスによる4枚組。本当にもううんざり。これで最後でしょうと言ったところだが、特典CDRに釣られて購入してしまった◆実質1~2枚目はアナログブートのコピーでEQ違い2種、3~4枚目がネット音源のコピー編集と言ったところではないだろうか?
 

1 枚目は『狂気』部分のみを収録したアナログブートの名盤『The Best Of Tour 72』(LP)をコピーし、音質補正を施したと思われる音源を収録。ここでは「On The Run」の終盤から「Time」にかけて音量が徐々に下がっていく欠点を補正したようです。また、不安定なピッチも補正を施しているようです。インフォによると「Money」は曲中で露骨に下がっていき、「Us And Them」の出だしは既に半音近く下がっており、曲中カット後からピッチが元に戻るらしいです。確かに元々ピッチが不安定なせいでフニャフニャした印象の強い音なんで、補正した点は評価できるかも


2 枚目は先のアナログブート『 Best Of Tour 72』をそのまんまコピーしただけのものなんでしょうか。ただし、ちょっと聞く限りスクラッチノイズもほとんど気にならないようで、除去処理は施しているようだ。スクラッチ処理のみで音的に下手なEQを施さない点は良いと思う。1~2枚目は、元々カットのあった「Time」3:37、「Us And Them」2:00、「Eclipse」のフェイドアウトなどのカットはそのままのようです


3~4 枚目には、1~2枚目のソースとは別のオーディエンスソースを収録しており、こちらは全曲収録の模様。以前この日の全長盤と謳われた『TIME ENDS』(2CD)はインチキクレジットミスだったので、4枚目のライブ後半部分を初めて収録したブートと言うことになり、ソース自体も全編ブートとしては初登場だが、既にネット上で無料で配布されている音源であり、単なるそのネット音源のコピーという可能性も大w音質は1~2枚目の部分には劣る。


◆ ジャケはコーティング仕様で、巷で評価が今一であるジャケットデザインをなんとかしたいと言う努力は伺えるのだが、今回のジャケはダメ。表ジャケはアナログブートで有名な「銀豚」ジャケをコピーしたものだが、画像がピンぼけで、色もオリジナルにはほど遠く不自然だ。文字は手間でも打ち直すなどのセンスが欲しいところ。裏ジャケの色は悪くないが、曲目クレジットの配置が非常にセンスがない。最初3枚組かと思ったぜw



 

 

 


 


 

Homepage           !!!All Scans taken from my own collection !!!           Bookmark
 

© Site design, implementation, and maintenance by  Holger Kaminski © 2000-2025


All trademarks and copywrites remain the property of their owners. 
The contents of this entire website are presented here as a non-profit 
and non-subscription service intended for the non-commercial purposes of criticism, 
research, comment, education, and archiving use only. 
Articles and images on this site are reproduced for reference, research and comment only. 
Copyrights are retained by the original author, artist or publisher.

This site is a tribute to the band: the past and present members, and their activities, whether musical or not.